Jesusfreakhideout.com celebrates 30 Years online in 2026... Get Your Music - and everything else - on Amazon! All purchases made on Amazon through this link earn a commission for Jesusfreakhideout.com!
Jesusfreakhideout.com celebrates 30 Years online in 2026... Get Your Music - and everything else - on Amazon! All purchases made on Amazon through this link earn a commission for Jesusfreakhideout.com!

Lindsay McCaul
If It Leads Me Back



Artist Info: Discography
Album length: 11 tracks: 41 minutes, 26 seconds
Street Date: January 17, 2012


 
IfItLeadsMeBack
READER RATING:  IfItLeadsMeBack
/ 5.0 (0 votes)

It's a good time to be a woman in music, perhaps for the first time in years. Not so long ago, industry watchers and music fans were commenting on the lack of female presence in CCM, but, though Christian music's most popular acts are still quite male-led, it doesn't take more than a glance at recent signings, new releases, and music news to notice the next generation of ladies stepping into the field.

Among those new faces is Lindsay McCaul, a songwriter who brings something refreshing with her debut If It Leads Me Back. Last year, her single "Say My Name" and follow-up EP, as well as touring with Casting Crowns and Sanctus Real, made the introductions and provided a preview of her new work in progress. Though her "day job" is on the worship team at Harvest Bible Chapel in Chicago, her personal musical efforts don't necessarily fall into the expected genre. Her inviting style and introspective yet vertical writing lead the way into a different sort of worship album.

The best way to describe McCaul's sound is thoughtful, songwriterly acoustic pop, though even that label might be contradictory. It's acoustic, but not folky; accessible, but not too poppy; vertically focused, but not worship in the usual sense. Most noticeable from the start is her unassuming voice. The current trends for women in music tend toward huge, powerful vocals, but McCaul's soothing, restrained alto matches her down-to-earth musical personality. The result is something friendly to the radio listener, but unique enough to win over this music fan.

The album opens with a quiet piano and soft drums, and the echoing refrain of her first single "Say My Name." As the gentle ballad builds layers of drums, piano, and airy guitars behind her singing, it sets the tone and style. For the most part, quiet and thoughtful is the norm, though "Face to Face" and "You Never Change" bring a little upbeat flavor. The former has a fun pop energy with almost a classic Cindy Morgan vibe; the second takes a summery, cheerful acoustic guitar direction that fits right alongside her contemporary Jamie Grace. Another highlight is "Where Do You Go," which brings in some spacious drums and gives a touch of atmosphere to the latter tracks. The piano-led "If It Leads Me Back" ends everything on a beautiful, prayerful note and stands out for its earnest simplicity.

The music isn't the star as much as the words. McCaul's heart is in her writing, and in 11 tracks she beautifully lays out her vision and reflections. Longing and returning weave a common thread throughout the record, with many of her songs drawing inspiration from people in the Bible. But rather than detach their stories into abstract concepts, she blends them into her own observations and experiences. The opening lines of "Say My Name" for example, recall the image of Lot's wife looking back at the burning city of her past "Tried to turn my head around / For too long just to see it now / That I can't erase any mistake." "Take My Hand" compares her own struggles with fear and faith to Peter walking on water; "If It Leads Me Back" begs, Job-like, "Don't let all my pain and weeping be in vain" even as she declares "You are all that I have left." The lyrics may sound somber, but they are tempered by great hope and gentle wisdom, and together tell a story that anyone who has traveled the way of faith can relate to.

Lindsay McCaul's debut doesn't blaze new trails or dazzle with flashy production or mindblowing vocals, but it does show off what she does best, giving a home to her personal songwriting and offering a refreshing and lovely new release to the CCM scene. Her honest lyricism, warm voice, and relaxed style blend into an inviting debut worth getting to know this winter.

- Review date: 1/15/12, written by Jen Rose of Jesusfreakhideout.com



(JFH Sponsor Spot)

Get a FREE month of VidAngel on us when you sign up!

 

Record Label: Reunion Records
Album length: 11 tracks: 41 minutes, 26 seconds
Street Date: January 17, 2012
Buy It: Amazon.com

  1. Say My Name (3:32)LYRICS
  2. Ready (3:36)LYRICS
  3. Come Rest (3:27)LYRICS
  4. Take My Hand (3:12)LYRICS
  5. Face To Face (3:24)LYRICS
  6. You Never Change (3:35)LYRICS
  7. Speak (3:32)LYRICS
  8. Hold On To Me (3:53)LYRICS
  9. Where Do You Go (4:10)LYRICS
  10. Let Go (4:47)LYRICS
  11. If It Leads Me Back (4:25)LYRICS

 

 Sample the Music

 

 



 

 

go to main Album review page
go to Album review archive

 

 

                 
Get a FREE month of VidAngel on us when you sign up!

Search JFH



This Tuesday, March 24, 2026
ALBUMS
Philip Anthony Rare Form (independent)

This Friday, March 27, 2026
ALBUMS
Romy Fay The Chosen Adventures (Vol. 1) [feat. Romy Fay] [Capitol CMG]
Gaither I Go To The Rock [Gaither]
Kelo & DreBeeze Da Godson TRAP WORSHIP 2 - Single [Syntax]
Limoblaze Solid Ground - EP [Reach]
Jason McGee & The Choir Another Tomorrow [CDAC]
NEEDTOBREATHE The Long Surrender [UMG]
Point of Grace Lady Wisdom [Curb]
Tommee Profitt The Resurrection of the King [Capitol CMG]
Tommy Royale ChurchBoy [Capitol CMG]
Various Artists We Shall Behold Him Tribute to Dottie Rambo [Daywind]

SINGLES
29:11 Worship The King and The Lamb - Single [Dream Worship]
B. Cooper Driver's Seat - Single [RMG Amplify]
Bethel Music Cathedral (Live at Church) (feat. Jonathan David & Melissa Helser) - Single [Bethel]
Chris Caro Noah's Song - Single [Syntax]
Franni Cash Raised by Wolves - Single [Capitol CMG]
Steven Curtis Chapman & Miel San Marcos Cinderella (Espańol) - Single [The Fuel]
ChristianXXII Glory - Single [Wick Media]
Cutright Nasty - Single [Syntax]
Evelyn Cormier Leaning on Jesus - Single [BEC]
ETSU Bluegrass Pride Band The First Time I Heard About Heaven - Single [Daywind]
FORREST FRANK x DAWN PATROL SOS - Single [Riverhouse]
Freedom Church Is He Not Worthy - Single [Dream Worship]
Justin Gambino Let Me Not Forget - Single [Residence]
Abbie Gamboa The Wonderful Blood (Amazon Music Original) - Single [Anotherland]
Amy Grant How Do We Get There From Here (feat. Ruby Amanfu) - Single [AG]
Philippa Hanna Citizen (feat. Israel Houghton & Moses Bliss) - Single [Integrity]
Benjamin William Hastings x Aodhán King Hollow Grave - Single [Capitol CMG]
J. Suthern Hicks You Are Loved - Single (independent)
Tasha Layton x Claire Leslie Whispers - Single [BEC]
Patrick Mayberry Three Days Later - Single [Provident/Sony]
Matthew Plante Love You Have - Single [Dream]
Q-Flo Midnight Matcha - Single [Syntax]
River Valley AGES Anxious for Nothing - Single [BEC]
Angelina Saathoff Butterflies & Goodbyes (Feat. PAIGE) - Single (independent)
The Sagehens Dumb & Drummer - Single [Velvet Blue]
Saints in Exile My Mind is a Prison (Orchestral Remix) - Single [Syntax]
SEU Worship A Forgiving God (Moment) - Single [Provident/Sony]
Signum Regis Throne Of Gold - Single [Fireflash]
Switchfoot Wake Up, Mr. Crow - Single [By Design/BMG]
Lauren Talley Walls - Single [Horizon]
tonyxtrotter UNTIL THE GOSPEL ft. KJ-52 - Single [Syntax]
Vertical Kings 20-Something - Single [Covenant Music]
Wilson Fairchild Lean On Me - Single [Gaither]

Next Friday, April 3, 2026
ALBUMS
Meredith Andrews Live From Liberty University (with Liberty Worship Collective) [Curb]
Peech. Small Town America (Vol. 2) - EP [Capitol CMG]
Michael Sweet The Master Plan [Frontiers]

SINGLES
ANTHNY x Kierra Sheard show up - Single [Provident/Sony]
FORREST FRANK x DAWN PATROL Waste Some Time - Single [Riverhouse]
Omega Levine All Things New - Single (independent)
Oyinbrakemi Goosebumps - Single (independent)
To Fight Fo Alive - Single (independent)
Bay Turner Redeemer - Single [Centricity]


For all release dates, click here!
 

Purchase Original Art Prints, Drawings, Stickers, Bookmarks and more from JFH's own John DiBiase!
Need proofreading and editing help? We've got you covered! Click here to learn more
Check out depositphotos for royalty free images