Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 14!
Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 14!

JFH Music Review


Jars of Clay, Frail
CLICK COVER TO ENLARGE

Jars of Clay
Frail



Artist Info: Discography
Genre(s): Indie / Acoustic / Folk
Album length: 9 tracks: 36 minutes, 50 seconds
Street Date: 1994


READER RATING:   


Before there was "Flood." Before Jars of Clay's self-titled debut turned Christian alternative music on its head. Before late-night TV, festival main stages, and the surreal blur of major-label-life, there was Frail.

It didn't start as a career move. It started as homework. Four college friends, barely out of their teens, were handed a class project and decided to turn it into something more. They borrowed what they could, layered acoustic guitars over woodwinds, strings, and electronic hip-hop drum loops, and wrote lyrics that read like poetry. It was fearless, unpolished, and utterly unlike anything else in the Christian music world in 1994.

That's the part that still stuns me: the maturity and emotional depth from musicians so young. They weren't chasing a chart position or polishing a "brand." They were chasing beauty, mystery, and truth. And without knowing it, they were building the foundation for one of the most important albums in the genre's history.

Within a year, "Flood" would crash onto both Christian and mainstream radio, a song so undeniable it blew open doors that had long been shut. But here, on Frail, you can hear the moment before the dam broke. The quiet before the rush. The creative spark before the spotlight. The tracklist tells its own story: seven songs would be reworked with fuller production for the debut; "Sinking," "Flood," and "Blind" hadn't yet been born, while "Fade to Grey" and "Frail" would resurface years later on Much Afraid.

Listen to "Liquid" here and you hear a promising sketch -- militant drums, wah-wah guitar from Matt Bronleewe, monk chants wrapped in deep reverb. It's less lush than the label version, but the yearning is almost stronger in its limitations. "Fade to Grey" flirts with trip-hop beats and spoken-word samples. "Frail" arrives as a lean, lyric-less instrumental, shorter than the later version but still cinematic. And "Love Song for a Savior," even in rough form, still aches for intimacy with God in a way that defies its age.

What makes Frail remarkable isn't just that it's good "for a college demo." It's that it's complete: emotionally alive, brimming with conviction, doubt, and longing. It's the raw sketch where all the lines that would define Jars of Clay are already drawn. If the 1995 debut is the cathedral, Frail is the blueprint drawn on a dorm room floor -- with pencil, prayer, and the kind of youthful daring that can change the course of music history. For those who've been here since the beginning, it's like finding an old journal entry and remembering exactly how it felt. For the uninitiated? It's proof that great things can start small, fragile, and full of hope.

- Review date: 9/22/25, written by Josh Balogh of Jesusfreakhideout.com



(JFH Sponsor Spot)

Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 14!

 

. Record Label: None
. Album length: 9 tracks: 36 minutes, 50 seconds
. Street Date: 1994

  1. Liquid (3:22)
  2. Boy On A String (Sunflower Song) (3:26)
  3. Art In Me (3:39)
  4. He (5:13)
  5. Fade To Grey (4:58)
  6. Frail (4:04)
  7. Like A Child (4:47)
  8. Love Song For A Savior (4:35)
  9. Four Seven (2:46)

 



Leave a Comment

 

 

go to main Album review page
go to Album review archive

 

 

                 
Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 14!

Search JFH



This Wednesday, October 22, 2025
SINGLES
Phil Wickham Fear Has No Power - Single [Fair Trade]

This Friday, October 24, 2025
ALBUMS
John Allan Resurrection Power - EP [Centricity]
Dan Bremnes The Villain - EP [Curb]
Clear Convictions Endure (2025 Remaster) [Resuscitation]
Fepeste This World Ain't Mine to Change [Velvet Blue]
gio. FINE BY ME [Capitol CMG]
God Behind Bars Music Live From Angola Prison Vol. 1 [Provident]
Hulvey HE WILL RETURN - EP [Reach]
Brandon Lake Amazon Music Songline [Provident]
Latter Day Exploits Within Consumed (Expanded Edition) [Charon Collective]
VaShawn Mitchell SOUNDCHECK [Fair Trade]
MORIAH Nice Life - EP [F2]
Tyson Motsenbocker Modern Worries [Tooth & Nail]
Smalltown Poets St. Augustine (independent)
Zahriya Zachary Rediscovery [Bethel]

SINGLES
29:11 Worship, Zion Rempel You Never Fail (feat. Emily Guy) - Single [DREAM]
The Band JAREN Poetic - Single [Hit and Run]
Joe L Barnes Grief, Joy, Gratitude - Single [Provident]
Chad Cory, Zacardi Cortez My First Love (Remix) - Single [DREAM]
Leanna Crawford Beginning Of Your Grace - Single [Provident]
darthy Juniper Tree - Single [WieRok]
EJ Swavv & Jericko Love Like This - Single [Syntax]
Emerson Day Midnight Hour - Single [Fair Trade]
Good Weather Forecast lows2highs - Single [DREAM]
goodwill. REST - Single [Syntax]
Grace + Max Rich - Single [WieRok]
Mat Kearney Good Old Days - Single (independent)
Kelo Car Freestyle - Single [Syntax]
Vic Lucas I Need You (ft. IsaiahLaRoi) - Single [Syntax]
Jamie Macdonald You Can't Take My Song - Single [Capitol CMG]
Myles Maestro No Place - Single [Syntax]
Mercy Tribe Music The King is in the Room (feat. Ayiesha Woods) - Single (independent)
Mountains in the Sea Breakthrough - Single [DREAM]
Razzie & Glenn Ray Second Chances - Single [Syntax]
Seph Schlueter Already On The Way (feat. Benjamin William Hastings) - Single [Provident]
Tomb Slayer The Christmas Lamb (feat. Khristian Dentley & Sarah Whittemore) - Single [Tomb Slayer]
tonyxtrotter, Yung Drew, Wayne Klassik HOLY HOLY HOLY - Single [Syntax]
The Undertaking! All Smiles - Single (independent)
Unseen Faith Cold Resolve - Single [Rottweiler Records]
Kim Zamolo Your Ways Are Higher - Single (independent)

VINYL
Clear Convictions Endure [Resuscitation]

Next Friday, October 31, 2025
ALBUMS
Hope Deferred Darkness Remains [The Charon Collective]
MORIAH Nice Life - EP [F2]
Testimony of Apocalypse Agony in the Garden [Roxx Records]

SINGLES
Dreamers My Heart His Home - Single [DREAM]
Roxanne Grace Try Again - Single [DREAM]
Lock & Chi Do To Me - Single (independent)
John Long Simple Pursuit - Single (independent)
Warren Zeiders How Great Thou Art - Single [Warner]


For all release dates, click here!
 

Purchase Original Art Prints, Drawings, Stickers, Bookmarks and more from JFH's own John DiBiase!
Need proofreading and editing help? We've got you covered! Click here to learn more
Check out depositphotos for royalty free images