Listen to the new album by Katie Lighty!
Listen to the new album by Katie Lighty!

JFH Staff Review

Saint, Crime Scene Earth 2.0

Crime Scene Earth 2.0

Artist Info: Discography
Genre(s): Metal
Album length: 10 tracks: 41 minutes, 40 seconds
Street Date: January 19, 2010


The career of the Oregon-born band, Saint, can be roughly divided into three distinct periods. The band made its opening bow during the early eighties and filled the better part of that decade churning out a series of classic metal efforts chock-full of churning guitars, soaring vocals and apocalyptically-inspired lyrics. Perhaps understandably, the band sat out the following ten years, as artists who plied their trade in grunge, rap-rock and nu-metal rendered those who favored the previous decade's straight-ahead metal aesthetic all but passť. And the third, and current, era, which began with their reformation in 1999, has found the band mostly picking up where they left off, offering fans a second helping of the music that first inspired them to craft their debut six-song EP back in 1984.

The original Crime Scene Earth album, released in 2008, featured front man Josh Kramer's vocals on only three tracks, while bassist Richard Lynch handled singing the remaining six non-instrumental cuts. For the reissue, Lynch's vocals -- which were nearly universally panned by long-time fans -- were removed and replaced by Kramer's newly-recorded contributions. Likewise, the original production, which was, even to the most gracious ears, both thin and muddy, was given an overhaul to bring it closer to snuff.

While this sort of dual-upgrade approach might look good on paper, it winds up playing out far less impressively in actual practice. Firstly, Kramer delivers his vocals in much the same style as Lynch's original contributions, meaning that any difference between the two is modest, at best, even to the most finicky ears. And although the updated production is admittedly somewhat fuller and clearer, it still falls well shy of current-day standards; sounding, for all intents and purposes, like that of a low-budget demo.

That being said, given the host of shortcomings intrinsic to the 2008 iteration, all such tinkering was arguably an uphill battle from the start. The lack of strong melody or catchy foundational riff causes songs like "The Judas in Me" to spin aimlessly in place without ever grabbing the listener's ear or going anywhere. Even more noticeably, disjointed entries like "Too Many" and "Bended Knee" sound as if Kramer and his cohorts laid down their vocal and instrumental contributions without listening to the other party as they did so. And the screeched chorus of "Half a Times Measure" and the almost Strong Bad-esque growled vocal outro to the title track will likely come across as borderline caricatures of the heavy metal idiom, even to some of the genre's most ardent enthusiasts.

To be fair, the album isn't completely without bright spots. It is telling, though, that the strongest point in the proceedings, by a long shot, comes in the form of the Judas Priest cover, "Invader," whose memorable melody line and rock-solid riffs add together to veritably dwarf the cuts that precede and follow it. Hats off to the band for attempting to spiff up the sonics and for returning Kramer to what many a diehard fan considers his rightful post behind the mic. But even with these external embellishments firmly in place, the sum total of the group's best intentions aren't enough to salvage what is, at its core, one of their weakest and most undistinguished efforts to date.

- Review date: 4/25/18, written by Bert Gangl of

Listen to the new album from Jack Izaak!


. Record Label: Retroactive Records
. Album length: 10 tracks: 41 minutes, 40 seconds
. Street Date: January 19, 2010
. Buy It: Apple Music
. Buy It: iTunes
. Buy It:

  1. The Conquest (1:20)
  2. Half A Times Measure (5:59)
  3. Terror In The Sky (5:27)
  4. Everlasting God (4:18)
  5. Crime Scene Earth (4:22)
  6. The Judas In Me (3:31)
  7. Too Many (5:01)
  8. Invader (4:14)
  9. Bended Knee (3:29)
  10. Lost (4:03)


 JFH Album Sample Player


Leave a Comment

comments powered by Disqus



go to main Album review page
go to Album review archive


(JFH Sponsor Spot)



Listen to the new album from Jack Izaak!

Search JFH

This Monday, August 3, 2020
Jonah Fear (feat. Anomaly) - Single (independent)

This Friday, August 7, 2020
Apollo LTD Patience - Single [Centricity]
Disciple Darkness Dies - Single [Tooth & Nail]
Grandpa Loves Rhinos Searching in the Sarchasm [Indie Vision Music]
Jason Gray Glory Days - Single [Centricity]
Coby James Whatever - Single [Centricity]
Lydia Laird Lydia Laird - EP [Provident]
North Point Worship Praise Your Name [Centricity]
John Schlitt Go Vinyl [4K]
Seventh Day Slumber Unseen: The Lion - EP [Rockfest]
We The Kingdom Holy Water [Capitol CMG]

Next Thursday, August 13, 2020
Various Artists Songs We've Been Trying to Tell You About (And Others We Haven't), Volume 9 [JFH Music]

Next Friday, August 14, 2020
Bride Drop (25th Anniversary Edition) [Girder Records]
Tori Kelly Solitude EP [Capitol]
Life.Church Worship Jesus Is Near EP [DREAM Worship]
PEABOD Heavenly Father - Single [Centricity]
Kim Walker-Smith Wild Heart (Live) [Sparrow/Jesus Culture]

For all release dates, click here!

Listen to the new single from Melanie Waldman!

Listen to the new album from The Grace Collective!