Listen to the new album from Elias Dummer!
Listen to the new album from Elias Dummer!

JFH Staff Review

Lindsay McCaul, One More Step

Lindsay McCaul
One More Step

Artist Info: Discography
Genre(s): Pop
Album length: 11 tracks: 41 minutes, 5 seconds
Street Date: August 19, 2014

Life can change so much in a short amount of time, and for Lindsay McCaul, that statement is not just a cliché. Over the past two years since her debut album released, the promising new artist saw a lot of big life changes. From great personal loss of family members, to a long distance move and a new label home, these many altered paths converge on her newest release, One More Step. There's a touch more pop gloss over some of the tracks this time around, but the songs themselves stay true to her writer's heart, and tell the stories of God's faithfulness every step of the way.

The album opens with a pair of upbeat pop songs, the kind that shimmer with mass appeal. "Empty Handed" leads the way as the record's first radio single, but despite the driving beat and catchy hook, it sets the record's deeper emotional tone as well. Her vocals are understated and joyful, but her lyrics admit total dependence, having nothing to bring but open hands before God. It's the best place to begin for an album about the unfolding story of God's provision, and that theme continues with "A Little," a song that delivers a singable pop hook and the assurance that "a little faith, little love / will be more than enough." These two are a good bit more layered and less hushed than her debut, and in that respect more radio friendly, but they certainly aren't throwaway tracks in the record's greater journey.

Her earnest and gentle delivery was one of the most endearing aspects of her music before, and that vibe is preserved for the bulk of this album. Some of the highlights on the poppier side are "The In Between," a song about trusting God while waiting through uncertainty, and the playful, ukelele-driven "Mess Like Me," a song with a self-explanatory title. Perhaps two of the most powerful moments, though, come in a pair of ballads within the album's first half.

"One More Step" is a highlight for sure, and its personal nature makes a unique choice for a title track. Written for her late father, it tells the story of their relationship with all the marks of a traditional father/daughter song -- walking through memories of a toddler's stumbling steps and a woman's wedding day -- yet the personal connection and sincere closing verse of this piano ballad save it from falling into sentimentality, and could possibly mark it as a future classic. It's appropriate that the following track, "With the Brokenhearted," a duet with Brandon Heath, offers the comfort of a reminder of God's closeness in the midst of a broken heart. The pain of loss and the comfort of mercy meet in these two songs, and they form the heartbeat of this record.

Lindsay McCaul's earlier album was impressive in its mature songwriting and understated, organic sound, and One More Step does not disappoint as a followup. It doesn't beg to stand out, become a hit record, or try to reinvent her art, but it does mark a progression in the right direction and offers an encouraging collection of honest songs for those willing to spend time listening. For that, it's another step in a bright future career, and a lovely re-introduction to a writer worth getting to know.

- Review date: 8/18/14, written by Jen Rose Yokel of


. Record Label: Centricity Music
. Album length: 11 tracks: 41 minutes, 5 seconds
. Street Date: August 19, 2014
. Buy It: iTunes
. Buy It: AmazonMP3
. Buy It:

  1. Empty Handed (3:53)
  2. A Little (3:04)
  3. Jesus Be (3:24)
  4. One More Step (4:06)
  5. With The Brokenhearted (feat. Brandon Heath) (4:34)
  6. Reaching Arms (3:36)
  7. The In Between (3:17)
  8. Mess Like Me (3:37)
  9. Rules The World (3:30)
  10. Love Won't Give Up (4:06)
  11. More Certain Than The Stars (4:01)


Leave a Comment



go to main Album review page
go to Album review archive


JFH Sponsor Spot:



Listen to the new album from Elias Dummer!

Search JFH

Music Out This Week

This Friday, February 22
For All Seasons Light and Momentary - Single [Centricity]
James Gardin Sweet Jesus EP [illetct]
London Gatch New Stories [BEC Worship]
Plumb Somebody Loves You - 2-Track Single [Centricity]
Michael W. Smith AWAKEN: The Surrounded Experience [The Fuel]
The Tommies Reunion The Tommies Reunion [Tyscot]
UPPERROOM To The One [The Fuel]

Next Friday, March 1
Abandon Kansas alligator: live at Smoakstack (independent)
7eventh Time Down Brand New Day [BEC]
Demon Hunter War [Solid State]
Demon Hunter Peace [Solid State]

For all release dates, click here!

New Music Reviews

Watch the new music video from Elias Dummer!

New Indie Reviews

New Movie Reviews

  • Image Glass
    PG-13 (Theatrical)

Free MP3 Downloads