Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 14!
Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 14!

JFH Indie Review

JFH Indie Inspection Review

Too Big To Fail

Jay Tholen
Control Me

Street Date: 2010
Style: Experimental
Buy It: JayTholen.net


Everything about the works of Jay Tholen is experimental. From the album covers to the themes, straight on down to the music itself. His projects range from albums like The Usurper Must Die!!! ("a nineteen minute avant-pop prog-hop onslaught of righteous rage") to The Great Hylian Revival, which uses music from the Nintendo 64 classic The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time to compose songs about Jesus. He puts out albums on a fairly regular basis, the latest of which is a full-length experiment entitled Control Me. Upon reading Tholen's own description of the album, you would know precisely what you were in for before even listening. He said he "layered the songs beyond recognition until they became what they are now: schizophrenic heaps of sound. Everything from Shoegaze to Prog Rock to Schmaltzy 50's Pop is emulated beneath layers of manipulated waveforms and vinyl samples." It couldn't be described any better as some songs have so much going on at once that you almost have to wonder if it was actually two different songs that Tholen mashed together. At the same time, the music has its moments of beauty. He uses a lot - a lot - of retro, 8-bit music, and he mixes it together with other instruments, such as ukeleles, drums and keyboards to create weird, albeit crafty, music. At times, they can be a little off-putting, but other times they're fully engaging. Take the next-to-last song "Eagle Feather, Falcon Claw" for instance. A five-part story, it sits within close proximity to eleven minutes in length, but the music plays a big part in the song not feeling needlessly dragged out as some lengthy tracks can feel. Some other highlights (as far as the music is concerned) are "Altars," "Bleeding Over" and the jazzy "I Know." As far as the vocals and lyrics, Tholen reminds me a lot of John Ringhofer of indie act Half-Handed Cloud. Like Ringhofer, Tholen uses minimal lyrics with lots of imagery per song, while singing with a voice that wouldn't make it past the audition phase of American Idol. To his credit, this obviously isn't what he's hoping to attain. It's also nice to hear some electronic music with vocals that aren't completely smothered with auto tune. At the same time, the songs would probably fair better with some smoother vocals instead of the sporadic quasi-melodies and crazy singing. That being said, Tholen is talented, and Control Me is worth a listen. It'd be interesting to hear his previous work and to see where he goes from here. If you want to hear more of his previous work, you can download almost all of his albums for free through his website, jaytholen.net. While you're there, give Control Me a listen. You may just find something to like about it.

- Review date: 11/21/10, written by Scott Fryberger of Jesusfreakhideout.com



(JFH Sponsor Spot)

Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 14!

 

 

go to main Indie review page
go to Indie Review Index

 

                 
Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 14!

Search JFH



This Friday, October 17, 2025
ALBUMS
ANTHNY DIARY ENTRY 1 [Provident]
Blanca Full Bloom [Curb]
Chris Blue Every Day Is Christmas [Gaither]
Geoff Moore and The Distance Foundations (Re-Release) [Girder]
Geoff Moore and The Distance A Place To Stand (Re-Release) [Girder]
Nate Parrish Make Me A Mountain (independent)
Psallos The New and Better Way: Hymns of Hebrews (independent)
Anne Wilson Stars [Capitol CMG]

SINGLES
F'rael God's Wheel (ft. TRYBISHOP) - Single [Syntax]
LEON Undefeated - Single [El Rescate Music]
No Vain Glory UNLEADED - Single [Syntax]
REFVGE, Cyfë II & WAY? U P W A R D S ft. Bianca Silver & Josh LeCroy - Single [Syntax]
Rhymes In Harmony & MAYIA My Sister - Single [Syntax]
Anton Scholl Born To Love You - Single [Near Kingdom]
Nathan Sheridan Don't Lose Hope - Single [WieRok]
SNT. VINCENT Feast of the Saints - Single [Syntax]
Vic Lucas, Essence Natay & Ashleey Barnes Let it Rain - Single [Syntax]
Zane Vickery All Things New - Single (independent)

DVD
Chris Blue Every Day Is Christmas DVD [Gaither]

Next Friday, October 24, 2025
ALBUMS
John Allan untitled EP [Centricity]
Dan Bremnes The Villain - EP [Curb]
Clear Convictions Endure [Resuscitation]
Fepeste This World Ain't Mine to Change [Velvet Blue]
gio. FINE BY ME [Capitol CMG]
Tyson Motsenbocker Modern Worries [Tooth & Nail]
Smalltown Poets St. Augustine (independent)
Zahriya Zachary Rediscovery [Bethel]

SINGLES
29:11 Worship, Zion Rempel You Never Fail (feat. Emily Guy) - Single [DREAM]
Chad Cory, Zacardi Cortez My First Love (Remix) - Single [DREAM]
darthy Juniper Tree - Single [WieRok]
Emerson Day Midnight Hour - Single [Fair Trade]
Good Weather Forecast lows2highs - Single [DREAM]
Grace + Max Rich - Single [WieRok]
Mercy Tribe Music The King is in the Room (feat. Ayiesha Woods) - Single (independent)
Mountains in the Sea You Never Fail (feat. Emily Guy) - Single [DREAM]
Tomb Slayer The Christmas Lamb (feat. Khristian Dentley & Sarah Whittemore) - Single [Tomb Slayer]
The Undertaking! All Smiles - Single (independent)

VINYL
Clear Convictions Endure [Resuscitation]


For all release dates, click here!
 

Purchase Original Art Prints, Drawings, Stickers, Bookmarks and more from JFH's own John DiBiase!
Need proofreading and editing help? We've got you covered! Click here to learn more
Check out depositphotos for royalty free images