"Where the Falls Begin," from the deluxe edition of The Everglow, was the first time a Mae song didn't click with me. After some time, I started liking it. Eventually, I loved the song so much that I was primed and ready for an album that continued in its musical direction. What we received instead, with the release of 2007's Singularity, was essentially the opposite, and I hated it. I likewise had little taste for 2009's (m)orning, and multiple years would pass before I'd give those albums a second chance. Now, both albums are all-time favorites of mine. Strangely, it seemed like Mae was always a few steps ahead of me, and eventually, I'd catch up with them and fall in love with their music.
After a long drought, the band has returned with the sort-of self-titled record, Multisensory Aesthetic Experience, and it's not the album many Mae fans will be expecting. For fans of the 3.0 EP, which gave us about half of the album two months ahead of time, the full-length is likely to feel like a bait-and-switch. There are no other songs on the album comparable to "5 Light Years," which is as thrilling and adventurous as (a)fternoon, nor is there anything else as immediate and catchy as "Let It Die," which recalls Destination: Beautiful and The Everglow in the best of ways. Even the official version of "A Race for Our Autonomy" fails to live up to its acoustic counterpart, lasting an additional two minutes with a big, horn-assisted outro that awkwardly sounds like a brand new song. In general, expectations set by the EP will cause this album to disappoint many listeners, especially on a first impression.
But is the album a disappointment overall? For anyone else thinking that "Let It Die" perfectly recaptured the Mae magic and hoping this album would contain a handful of similar gems, then yes, this album's going to disappoint. That single actually appears late in the track listing, as a bright spot in a set that prefers spacious and slow-burning over energetic and rocking. For example, the middle of the album places three songs together that all breach the six-minute mark. The first of these three, "You Fall When You Hesitate," flirts with a genre I can best describe as "progressive indie pop"; it might possibly be one of the album's best tracks, but it's a weird one that, personally, took me three listens before I could begin to understand or enjoy it. Still, "Hesitate" boasts some fantastic lyrics, which, like the 90's-alternative-influenced "No Promises," find singer Dave Elkins at his most thoughtful penmanship.
As fine-tuned as most of the production and lyrics are, though, the compositions themselves don't always seem finished. "Sing" and highlight "Simple Words" (which would've fit snugly on (e)vening) wrap up way sooner than they need to, while the fact that at least three songs have fade-out endings is, arguably, lazy. Similarly, the spoken word on "The Overview" feels like a cop-out, and the instrumental track "Flow" is more-or-less pointless. You know there's something wrong with the album's structure and pacing when "Our Love is a Painted Picture" doesn't fully come alive until the six-minute mark.
To the band's credit, Multisensory Aesthetic Experience is growing on me. And if history proves anything, it's that Mae's albums age well. I can imagine a future where I'll regret awarding this album only 3.5 stars. But from my current vantage point, it's impossible to tell whether Mae is two steps ahead of me or I'm two steps ahead of them, seeing through the cracks, perceiving how the members grew rusty during the hiatus, and noting how the album could've been stronger. Yet, at the very least, I'd rather let Mae make the music they want to make than waste my time clamoring for The Everglow 2. Hopefully, by the time Mae releases the next album, we'll find that this self-titled-ish release had more to love than I first gave it credit for.- Review date: 11/29/18, written by Chase Tremaine of Jesusfreakhideout.com
Record Label: Tooth & Nail Records
|comments powered by Disqus|
|I AM THEY Announces Trial and Triumph Tour with Dan Bremnes and Elle Limebear|
Thu, 20 Jun 2019 12:40:00 EST
|Mac Powell and the Family Reunion Release Video for New Single, "Back Again"|
Wed, 19 Jun 2019 16:50:00 EST
|Avalon Announces New Album, New Headlining Tour|
Wed, 19 Jun 2019 16:20:00 EST
|Building 429, Premier Productions Announce Exclusive Touring Partnership|
Wed, 19 Jun 2019 15:15:00 EST
|Michael W. Smith Invites Fans to Celebrate "35 Years Of Friends" With Fall Tour|
Wed, 19 Jun 2019 14:50:00 EST
|Switchfoot Announce Special U.S. Fall Tour|
Tue, 18 Jun 2019 12:50:00 EST