Get Your Music on Amazon!
Get Your Music on Amazon!

JFH Music Review

Comrades, Safekeeper


Artist Info: Discography
Genre(s): Post Hardcore / Alternative Rock
Album length: 9 tracks: 33 minutes, 40 seconds
Street Date: May 6, 2014


Since its large-scale inception into thrash and heavy metal in the 1980s, screaming as a vocal style has been largely misunderstood and sometimes ridiculed. The implication is often that screaming is simply used by those who either can't sing, don't have anything to say, want to appear angry and edgy, or all three. This perception isn't helped by a slew of mediocre, monotone, and otherwise boring bands, throughout hard music, that often do fall into such stereotypes. But every so often, a band comes along that stands above the racket and brings a creative new perspective to the industry. One such band is the post-hardcore band Comrades, now almost ten years old. Their 2016 album Lone / Grey was critically acclaimed, but it was their 2014 project, Safekeeper, that catapulted them into prominence in the Christian post-hardcore scene.

The album begins with "Endless," which showcases the wide variety of styles that Comrades has adopted, transitioning from bassist Laura MacElroy's soft vocals to a passionate verse screamed by Ben Trussell, and back again, all riding on a beautiful series of instrumentals. This, in a sense, captures the essence of Comrades, balancing screamed and sung vocals almost perfectly, in a combination that works surprisingly well. "Endless" blends into "Roving," a long instrumental that exemplifies what could be described as "the other half" of what the listener will hear on Safekeeper. As the title indicates, it's a roving song, musically wandering all over the place. Even so, it's well executed, with noticeable contributions from all members of the band. The following track, "The Compass," features more excellent guitar work by Joe MacElroy and gang vocals near the end which give the song an anthemic feel.

Three tracks later, the song "Orphan Hymn" employs the same blend of styles as "Endless," making it an album highlight, and the spiritual predecessor to Lone / Grey's "Sheperd's Hymn." This is followed by two more instrumentals, "Haven," and "Severance," before the final track. "The End of This Story and the Beginning of All the Others" is a title drawn directly from the name of the final chapter of C.S. Lewis's "The Magician's Nephew," and it lives up to its namesake with a beautiful close to the album. While technically an instrumental, it features a thought-provoking spoken message that seems to perfectly sum up the album.

The main thing that detracts from this album is the at-times lengthy instrumental tracks. While these instrumentals are all musically sound, some of them fail to really hold the attention of the listener ("Calling Down Fire (To Keep Warm)" and "Severance"). With a run time of only 33 minutes, I can't help but feel as if Safekeeper could have been better as an EP, cutting a few of the more cumbersome instrumentals. Overall, though, it's still quite a good album in itself. While not perfect, it added a new and creative sound to the Christian post-hardcore scene and paved the way for Comrades' later success.

JFH Reader Review: Review date: 2/14/17, written by Lawson Pace for

(JFH Sponsor Spot)

Check out the new EP from Darby Hughes!


. Record Label: Blood & Ink Records
. Album length: 9 tracks: 33 minutes, 40 seconds
. Street Date: May 6, 2014
. Buy It: iTunes
. Buy It: AmazonMP3
. Buy It: Bandcamp
. Buy It: Vinyl

  1. Endless (5:20)
  2. Roving (4:46)
  3. The Compass (4:21)
  4. Pax (1:10)
  5. Calling Down Fire (To Keep Warm) (2:37)
  6. Orphan Hymn (4:30)
  7. Haven (1:44)
  8. Severance (4:08)
  9. The End of This Story and the Beginning of All the Others (5:04)


Leave a Comment



go to main Album review page
go to Album review archive


(JFH Sponsor Spot)



Check out the new EP from Darby Hughes!

Search JFH

Last Friday, December 2, 2022
Keith & Kristyn Getty Christmas Duets [Getty Music]
Danny Gokey The Greatest Gift: Songs for Christmas Eve EP [UMG]
Jason Ingram Basement Tapes Vol. III EP [Provident]
David Brymer, Chris Beland Harken [Integrated Music]
TobyMac The Goodness of Christmas EP [UMG]
Ronnie Martin Bells Merrily [Velvet Blue Music]
Leigh Nash The Tide Acoustic Sessions EP [Visionary]
Sheryl Lee Ralph Sleigh. [Peerless/Syntax]
Red Until We Have Faces: Live & Unplugged [RED]
Paul Zach Christmas Hymns [Integrated Music]

116, Limoblaze & Rehmahz Silent Night - Single [Reach]
Future of Forestry Emmanuel - Single (independent)
Kutless End of the World (feat. Disciple) - Single [BEC]
Alisha Quinonez Bello Jesús - Single [Lula Street]
The Wisecarvers Wrapped in Red - Single [Crossroads]

This Friday, December 9, 2022
Deep AL Brindle X Kids Out Of Love - Single [Tooth & Nail]

Next Tuesday, December 12, 2022
Keith Green The Studio Collection (6 CD Box Set) [Girder]

For all release dates, click here!

Listen to the New Album By Jack Robson!

Listen to the New Album By John Jay!

Check out depositphotos for royalty free images